@Scapexghost your question intrigued me enough to take a look at the scientific papers on this. I have never owned guppies, nor am I super knowledgable about genetics, so take it with a grain of salt. Just to look fancy I'll throw in a reference at the end, if someone wants to take a look. I won't bring too much new to the discussion, but hopefully this helps you forward. I'd also appreciate if someone with real experience in guppy genetics could chime in.
As others pointed out, the reason for males having red tails and the females blue, lies in the colour genes being on the sex chromosomes. In the case of guppies they're in the X- and Y-chromosomes. These are not quite like the human ones as far as I've understood, the Y-chromosome on guppies being larger and housing more genes than the human one. But they are otherwise similar enough for our purpouse. The colour coding genes are usually on the Y-chromosome, but they can jump (usually through crossing-over events) to the X-chromosome too. This is why guppy males are usually colourful, while female are drab, but also why the females too can get some colours.
In your case, my guess is that the father fish had a red tail gene on his Y-chromosome, while your mother fish had the blue tail gene on her X. Since females only get X-chromosomes they will also only inherit the blue tail. What makes me scratch my head however, is the fact that males get just red tails. See, both colours are dominant, so a male with X(blue) and Y(red) should theoretically express both and maybe have some blending of both. Or there should be some blue tailed mles, if the genes are shut off randomly. If that's not the case, then I would guess there are some male hormones that suppresses the expression on the X-chromosome (maybe the whole chromosome or maybe just some genes?). That's all I got for now, I'll await eagerly for the critics to tear me apart 😅
Here's a paper that kind of summarizes work on the colour genes involved:
Khoo, G., Lim, T. M., Chan, W.-K., Phang, V. P. E. 1999. Linkage Analysis and Mapping of Three Sex-Linked Color Pattern Genes in the Guppy, Poecilia reticulata. Zoological Science 16(6):893-903