FishNasty Posted February 5 Posted February 5 Hey everyone, I’m new to the forum thing. I was looking for any input on my dirted tank. It’s a 40 gallon but it’s 4 feet long and 16 inches high by 12 inches deep. It’s been running for about 4 months now it houses 12 galaxy rasbora, roughly 40 blue dream shrimp. 1 otocinclus ( there was 3 but I believe two were unhealthy and died shortly after getting them home) and a bunch of snails that came from plants. There is diatom algae that my Otocinclus and snails keeps under control. But now I’m starting to see some green algae just starting around the upper glass and drift wood. I don’t see much for nitrates either on my test strips. Would you add more otocinclus? More plants? Less light? Any ideas are welcome and thanks to anyone who can help out! i have well water so it’s very hard, but I think the fish like the water quality. Plants all seem healthy aswell. I run the lights for 8 hours on timers.
Creedmoor Aquatics Posted February 5 Posted February 5 I would run more plants. Ideally for a dirted tank I want the tank to be full with plants, at least to the point where I couldn't meaningfully add more plants due to lack of space in the substrate. 2 1
FishNasty Posted February 5 Author Posted February 5 Thank you for your reply, that will be my next plan of attack then. Would you suggest any plants in particular? The rotala and dwarf Lilly really grew like crazy after everything settled in. I’ve been replanting the rotala in the back right corner to try and fill the space. My swords and valasaneria have taken awhile but are starting to grow well now after melting and coming back.
Rube_Goldfish Posted February 5 Posted February 5 On 2/5/2024 at 7:27 PM, FishNasty said: Thank you for your reply, that will be my next plan of attack then. Would you suggest any plants in particular? The rotala and dwarf Lilly really grew like crazy after everything settled in. I’ve been replanting the rotala in the back right corner to try and fill the space. My swords and valasaneria have taken awhile but are starting to grow well now after melting and coming back. The easy answer is more of what's working, so more rotala and dwarf lily, and it sounds like swords and vallisneria are doing well, too. The tightwad in me likes stems of all kinds because they are so easy to trim and replant. With a shallow tank like that 40 breeder you might have luck with some kind of easy carpet, even without injected carbon dioxide. And there are so many kinds of crypts, and they're so low maintenance, toss a whole bunch in. 1
FishNasty Posted February 5 Author Posted February 5 Thanks rube_goldfish! I’m going to try some more stem plants for sure I like the crypts as-well. It’s very pricey for plants in Ontario. I paid 16.99 cad for 3 stems of bacopa carolinia at the big box store. I did have some Monte Carlo, I believe it was anyways. But it didn’t survive… I also used play sand which is very small grained, maybe that was the cause of death? I think it’s harder to get plants established. But it holds the dirt down very well. 1
Rube_Goldfish Posted February 5 Posted February 5 Do you have any fish clubs near you? My local club has a monthly meeting with an auction, and it can be a great place to get plants at great prices. Alternately, if you have any other local hobbyists, you might be able to buy or trade with them, too. I've never successfully grown a carpet, truth be told. One of these days! 1
FishNasty Posted February 5 Author Posted February 5 It’s something I would have to look into. I don’t know of any fish clubs or that there was such a thing. That’s a great idea though. I have had luck on Kijiji buying local plants and shrimp. Definitely better prices, but it’s hard to find local people with a variety of plants. do you have a Dirted tank you were trying to carpet in? 1
Rube_Goldfish Posted February 5 Posted February 5 Oh no, I've never tried a dirted tank. Truth be told, I've only even dabbled with aquasoil. But I realized that I was talking about carpeting plants and thought that I ought to give the caveat that I've never successfully done it myself. ACO has a club finder thing on their website, so maybe that'll work for you? https://www.aquariumcoop.com/apps/store-locator
FishNasty Posted February 6 Author Posted February 6 Fair enough, maybe one day you will go for it! It seems to be a lot of work to achieve a carpet. I would much rather just have a jungle of plants at this point. Through the link you sent I do see some in the major cities. Like Toronto and Ottawa. I will look into them they are about a 2-3 hour travel from where I live but it may be worth it. thanks for all your help!
FishNasty Posted September 2 Author Posted September 2 Update on my dirted tank as of September 2nd 2024. Took @Rube_Goldfish and @Creedmoor Aquatics advice. and I think it’s beginning to fill in much better after 7 months! 2
Creedmoor Aquatics Posted September 2 Posted September 2 Right on! It will take a while for all of your crypts to fully fill in, but keep trimming those stem plants and replanting the cuttings along the back and you'll be set for nutrient depletion. 1
FishNasty Posted September 2 Author Posted September 2 Definitely, ive been working on the back lately it’s very bare still. When you say nutrient depletion, will all the plants begin to die off? Or do you mean more of the excess nutrients?
Creedmoor Aquatics Posted September 2 Posted September 2 Just the excess nutrients. With it being a dirted tank it would take years of trimming plants out of the tank to deplete to the point the plants die off. 1
FishNasty Posted September 2 Author Posted September 2 That’s perfect! I would be pretty pissed if once it started to really fill in, all of sudden went downhill 😂 Maybe in another couple months I’ll give an update
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now