Jump to content

Not common 10 gallon stocking


beastie
 Share

Recommended Posts

Hello, I am looking for a (for now) hypothetical stocking advice on my 10 gallon.

it has some limitations that are making it too hard for me to chose. At this moment it has the potentially sick honey gourami which lost its mate over the weekend, after 5 weeks of owning them, no signs prior to death. I am going to watch it for a while and then most likely move it ot my big tank and place something else here in stead. The question is what.

This tank houses adult and baby tylomelania snails, which means what I add here cant be an antenna nipper or an aggressive or snail not compatible fish. This means no betta fish, no sparkling gourami, even the honey gourami was poking the baby snails sometimes. It also limits the bottom part of the tank, adding fish here would only stress the snail. So looking for a fish for the mid or upper levels of the tank. Fish that I dont already own, that are not overly boring (I feel like some of the small shoaling fish, when kept alone, just dont do much. All the micro rasboras, the ember tetras,...also I have hatchetfish, and after you get over the wow of their appearance, they just...hover). I absolutely detest neon tetras and their lookalikes and their genetic stocks are down the drain.

Given I have mostly soft water and pH under 7, I can rule out all the livebearers. I wouldnt be that comfortable with them in such small space either I fear.

There are also fish that I know are not possible to obtain here, like epiplatys annulatus (clown killifish) that I would like but cant get, even the honey gourami was an import from an import (we have the other gouramis, dwarf, thicklipped, but havent seen honeys here for years). I assume normal killifish would not work with the snails either. I used to have shelldwellers, so no to that too, I have shrimp in other tanks, white cloud minnows in other tank (I have five tanks, I know, crazy)

What I was considering were some nannostomus, though the news about their behavior vary, pygmy corydoras might be nice, but on their own they might be too shy. Am I overlooking something obvious or is there something you would get or see? Thank you so much for any tips

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 4/20/2023 at 4:37 PM, Chick-In-Of-TheSea said:

Perhaps corydoras catfish of some variety.  They are a schooling fish, but are quite active on all levels of the tank.  Caridina shrimp like soft water.

 

Thank you. I did have 10 corydoras sterbai here when this was a quarantine for three weeks before moving them to the big tank, and to be honest, it was quite boring. I dont think cories like to be alone, they were mostly hidden, unless food was involved they just stayed still and hidden. The pygmy might be a different story, but of the large varieties, I think they would be pretty simillar

Cardina are too sensitive since i do not have RO water and it is not that soft

I forgot to mention, out of those that I considered that might be good size wise are some of the Pseudomugil family or perhaps some Oryzias, ricefish family. I do not have any experience with them though

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've heard different thing about pygmies but mine aren't shy at all. They haven't ever been alone, I added my ember tetra first, but the tetra were very shy until I put the pygmies in. The pygmies weren't hesitant at all and are always out and about nibbling or napping out in the open. But I've read some people never see theirs so it's hard to know. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 4/20/2023 at 9:12 AM, Lennie said:

Very pretty. Do they breed as much as  shrimps do?

Mine haven't, but they are supposed to theoretically. I only started with 2 males and 2 females though, so you may want to start with a larger colony if you want them to breed. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 4/20/2023 at 7:20 PM, Ninjoma said:

Mine haven't, but they are supposed to theoretically. I only started with 2 males and 2 females though, so you may want to start with a larger colony if you want them to breed. 

My lfs was carrying them but I was scared to try them as I always keep community tanks. I couldnt be sure how peaceful they would be or what would I do with potential babies

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I recently acquired Pseudomugil luminatus. All the Pseudomugil act relatively similiar from my understanding. They stay mid to top. Are ideal for 10 gallons. Can go from 64-79 degrees and 6-8 ph. Very active, brightly colored snail safe. I have them with my breeding wizard snails they pay zero attention to. 
Mine are young but my understanding is their spawning dances and activities are quite a thing to see. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 4/20/2023 at 7:13 PM, Guppysnail said:

I recently acquired Pseudomugil luminatus. All the Pseudomugil act relatively similiar from my understanding. They stay mid to top. Are ideal for 10 gallons. Can go from 64-79 degrees and 6-8 ph. Very active, brightly colored snail safe. I have them with my breeding wizard snails they pay zero attention to. 
Mine are young but my understanding is their spawning dances and activities are quite a thing to see. 

Nice, they look.really awesome. I will read a bit more about them and they are in my top five now.

Btw i am slowly reading your journal but based on what you are keeping and breeding I am so in love with you 🙂 we should move in together and have lots of awesome tanks (you have better experience breeding ) 🙂 something to consider :))))

  • Love 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 4/20/2023 at 10:10 AM, Lennie said:

My lfs was carrying them but I was scared to try them as I always keep community tanks. I couldnt be sure how peaceful they would be or what would I do with potential babies

They are some of my favorite aquatic animals. I would definitely recommend trying them at some point. 

Edited by Ninjoma
spelling
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 4/20/2023 at 2:17 PM, beastie said:

Nice, they look.really awesome. I will read a bit more about them and they are in my top five now.

Btw i am slowly reading your journal but based on what you are keeping and breeding I am so in love with you 🙂 we should move in together and have lots of awesome tanks (you have better experience breeding ) 🙂 something to consider :))))

Thank you for such kind words. I often thought it would be lovely to live in a housing complex dedicated to freshwater Nerms 🤗. In recent months I have been dabbling in species I have little to no experience with. I love keeping a journal. I feel like the forum is a best friend standing beside me fishkeeping. Sharing the hobby always makes it more fun. 🤗

Edited by Guppysnail
  • Like 1
  • Love 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 4/20/2023 at 8:52 PM, xXInkedPhoenixX said:

I also love Blind Cave Fish, but again. Too big. 😞

What about a freshwater Pipefish? They need to be kept away from other fish species because they are slow feeders, they are super neat and might be worth a try. 

I have a group of Indostomus paradoxus in other tank:) they are amazing, but hardly move, can do with way smaller space and are not seen most of the time. Nice, but only for a true hobbyist 🙂

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

Even my second honey gourami passed, same symptomps as the previous, 7 weeks after purchase. Sad, but that means they are a no go fish.  I only seen them from one supplier so not going to risk another pair, even though I absolutely loved them. This means my 54l is empty again, except the tylomelania (rabbit) snails. I am also considering giving them away, the older ones have snail erosion because my water is soft and under 7 ph lately, despite water supplier saying I have 7,9 on entry water. All my tests are around 7 but not above.

I could either play with mineral salts and baking soda, or give them to someone who has better water conditions...not sure yet. I am again hunting for options. Good news is, I saw the pseudougil luminatus at the fish store last weekend and they have them avaiable. Same as furcatus and gertrudae, but one is too large and one is too territorial (per other keepers experience).

If you had an empty 54l tank (60x30x30 cm) with neutral and mostly soft water, what would you keep 🙂 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 5/1/2023 at 9:08 AM, beastie said:

Even my second honey gourami passed, same symptomps as the previous, 7 weeks after purchase. Sad, but that means they are a no go fish.  I only seen them from one supplier so not going to risk another pair, even though I absolutely loved them. This means my 54l is empty again, except the tylomelania (rabbit) snails. I am also considering giving them away, the older ones have snail erosion because my water is soft and under 7 ph lately, despite water supplier saying I have 7,9 on entry water. All my tests are around 7 but not above.

I could either play with mineral salts and baking soda, or give them to someone who has better water conditions...not sure yet. I am again hunting for options. Good news is, I saw the pseudougil luminatus at the fish store last weekend and they have them avaiable. Same as furcatus and gertrudae, but one is too large and one is too territorial (per other keepers experience).

If you had an empty 54l tank (60x30x30 cm) with neutral and mostly soft water, what would you keep 🙂 

I have issues with younger honey gouramis when I buy them. never had issues buying them larger. Highly recommend doing this. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 5/1/2023 at 10:08 AM, beastie said:

Even my second honey gourami passed, same symptomps as the previous, 7 weeks after purchase. Sad, but that means they are a no go fish.  I only seen them from one supplier so not going to risk another pair, even though I absolutely loved them. This means my 54l is empty again, except the tylomelania (rabbit) snails. I am also considering giving them away, the older ones have snail erosion because my water is soft and under 7 ph lately, despite water supplier saying I have 7,9 on entry water. All my tests are around 7 but not above.

 

You could add some crushed coral to the tank or in the filter to help with the snail shells. Other methods people have also used is crushed oysster or egg shells. Even if the water has a 7.9 pH, it may not have enough calcium and minerals for the snails to have healthy shells. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 months later...

I want to open this up again, because I am basically at the same situation again.

I have three tanks (one is a temporary one, hahaha ). One is a 40 liters long narrow, one is 54 liters standard 60x30x30cm, one is the temp 60 l cube, 40x40x40cm. All have sandy substrate, sponge filters, some live plants. I plan to buy some driftwood to help with the scape, I am not fan of rocks cause I think they just take away volume but dont add much to the fish or snails other than an obstacle.

What I have that needs to somehow fit into these three tanks is: 3 adult and like 9 baby rabbit snails of various sizes. 1 overaged neolamprologus multifasciatus, that cant be with any snails, hardly any fish too. 2 male endler guppies that could go to any of my other large tanks no issues. One possibly sick male bolivian ram that I want to observe out of a community for a little while, maybe treat. I suspect parasites but have nothing to treat with, as nothing is sold here.

Over the summer the breeder will provide me couple of clown killifish that I want to put in the 40l tank. Initially I thought I might move the rabbits there, but if the multie will still be alive, I guess it will cohabit with clown killifish and the snails can go there later on. The b-ram will go to the 60l cube for now, to watch and maybe treat or feed.

the 54l will be empty and if the b-ram is ok, the 60l cube will too be empty

I was toying with the following options - pea puffers for the 60l cube (needs more plants, the stone here might make sense). Sparkling gourami and scarlet badis combo in the 54liter tank (snails would have to go away in that case). Just sparkling gouramis and the snails in the 54 liters (risky as I cant find if they wont hurt the snail antenna). Scarlet Badis with the clown killifish in the 40l (due to same feeding requirements). Attempting to breed the sterbai corydoras I have in my other tank using the trio approach in the 54l or 60l without snails. Trying a pair of killifish in the 60l cube (again assume no snails). Getting a school of pseudomugil to the 54l with the snails. Try my hand at some goby fish

I absolutely do not want any boring schooling fish that are great in aquascapes, but otherwise not interesting in behavior (be it tetras, rasbora, cpd, kubotais,...). Also no to shrimp. Very much NO to a betta (no heater in either of those tanks and while now I am at 26 or so C, winter is closer to 20 and the heaters are just an eye sore).

The tanks, not finished as they are all missing something, be it a piece of driftwood or anything, are here:

I very much appreciate any ideas at all, because I have been mulling this over for months now, and all I keep coming up with are new options 😄 

IMG-1228.JPG

IMG-1221.JPG

IMG-1159.JPG

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Some less common inhabitants I have that a lower height tank and both cool temps are fine for that are with livebearing snails currently are Hara jerdoni dwarf anchor cats, Sewellia lineolata hillstream loaches, and African dwarf frogs, and Dario sp. Myanmar black tiger badis, Badis badis blue chameleon. These can all cohabitate but choose only 1 badis type  the tigers are small like scarlets the chameleons are larger but do not come out in daylight and like to dwell in cave structures  both badis types are cave spawners with the male being the parental care giver  

 

  • Love 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hara Jedoni were so long on my list, someone here even breeds them. But I understand they like flow and neither of these tanks has it. I have sewellia in a high flow tank, so I can check that box with "weird flat fish" 🙂

I will check what other badis species are available here, thank you

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@beastie Hara jerdoni actually do not like a lot of flow. If I turn the canister up to far they struggle  their pectorals being what they are they get blown about  

They prefer cool very oxygenated lower flow, a few airstones and you are good to go.  I keep the filtration set so I get surface agitation but the water body is has very little movement.

I just moved them to a new tank.  I indeed have 2 more than I purchased so that is a good breeding setup  

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...