Jump to content

Experience Keeping Corydoras on Sand vs Gravel


LadyoftheLake
 Share

Recommended Posts

I've seen the arguments for both gravel being fine and for sand being best. But what is your firsthand experience with this? have you actually experienced any problems? is so what were they and with what species on what substrate?

also have you personally observed any difference when dealing with larger vs smaller species?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've never used sand. Not to say i haven't thought about it. But reading about how it can trap gasses or suffocate plant roots i decided not to. I know some coarse sand types can mitigate that. Personally i use a rounded gravel. When i was little i had an albino cory on gravel. Now, i was a kid, but i dont' remember it being an issue. Right now i have panda corys on a rounded gravel (activ-flora). There's a handful of more blocky pieces but overall its rounded. I've only had these pandas a few weeks and they're basically an inch long. But so far they're having no ill effects from being on gravel. I use wafers, they eat their fill, take a nap, wake up and graze again. I don't see any redness or irritation on their bellies or barbels and their behavior seems pretty normal for corys. I spend a lot of time watching them because i love watching fish like that. Tirelessly working and foraging around, investigating and looking for things. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Some years back I had a paleatus corydoras get themselves stuck head first in the gravel substrate and die because I didn't  find them in time to see if I could have pulled them out and saved them. Was not something I enjoyed coming home from work to find. That weekend I caught all the fish and tore the tank down to remove the gravel and put sand in.

So I don't keep corydoras on gravel personally, though I know many have done it successfully for years. I use BDBS or ecocomplete in all my current tanks, and while the ecocomplete is somewhat rough, the grain size is much smaller than gravel and I've yet to see a corydoras manage to get themselves stuck in either, despite their snuffling and rooting around in the substrate. So I don't  really know if that one was a fluke or if they could actually do that more often, but I'm not going to take the chance to find out. 

I've never kept any of the 'smaller' corydoras species so I don't have any input there. I've kept paleatus, aeneus, sterbai, brochis and two species that I'm currently not sure on, though one may be ambiacus or aggasizii. Either way, they're not small either, around the same size as the c. Aeneus.

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I had a group of 8 paleatus in a 40 breeder with gravel with minimal issues, I had 2 pass a couple months ago but I believe it was an unrelated issue. I actually have the remaining 6 spawning on the glass but the plecos kept getting the eggs. Finally took the time to learn how to pull the eggs and was fortunate to get around 60 eggs a week ago and happy to state a high hatch rate. Planning on moving the group to a 20 by themselves but not sure what to use as substrate - will following this thread going forward. Thanks

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don’t think gravel is bad for them and they will root around in gravel. but I think It looks cooler and probably a more Natural behavior when they are on sand. In my cory breeding setups that I would typically keep bare bottom. I have started to put some river rocks in a line so that I can attempt to keep sand on one half of the tank so they can root around.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have a school of pygmy corys and my substrate is my eco complete. They are all fat, happy water derps and doing just fine. I ordered another larger air pump so I can my sponge filter/air stone and drop another just air stone in so they have farther to ride the bubbles.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...